Usability: Band-aids or Vitamins?

Posted by admin in user experience, user testing on August 8, 2005

The project is about to go into launch.  Weeks, months, if not years, of planning, designing, development and testing has gone into it.  Project managers, business analysts, developers, designers, testers and contractors have all been putting blood sweat and tears to make sure things go smoothly.  Of course, it’s seldom that everything is perfect – there is some smoke and mirrors (but only a few!).  But it’s version 1.0.  Version 1.0 always has problems we know about – we’ll fix them in version 2.0.

Then it happens.  Someone finds a problem because she had her friend use it when she was showing off her work – and he couldn’t for the life of him figure out how to work it.  He didn’t even notice the fancy new functions that took the team spent a lot of time arguing over.  Worse still, he is using one of the basic functions for something completely different to what the project team had intended.  There is a slight moment of panic.  Perhaps he’s an exception.  How could he not know how to work it?  It seems blindingly obvious.  A few more ‘corridor tests’ reveal the same worrying problem – no one seems to know to use it properly!

Just to be safe, the project manager gets someone to do some usability testing.  That should fix it.  They will come up with some ‘quick fixes’ and everything will now be fine.

Most readers on this newsletter will be familiar with similar stories, or have experienced it themselves.  While this narrative is somewhat dramatized, it’s not uncommon.  Say hello to the usability band aid.

In real life, band aids are messy.  They are seldom big enough to cover the wound.  It’s sticky, and it hurts to take it off.  They can increase the risk of infection and can even slow healing.   Unfortunately, the usability band aid is very similar to its real life counterpart.

Fortunately, it is possible to prevent the need for a band-aid altogether.  We’ve been fortunate enough to work with some clients who employ usability not as a messy band-aid near the end of the project, but more like vitamin supplements.  Vitamin styled usability is not only a good preventative; it can also serve as a powerful competitive advantage.

Good usability demonstrates respect for users.  It shows that customers’ needs have been considered from the start rather than added on as an afterthought.  While this simple truth is nothing new, it is surprising how seldom we see it exercised with websites, intranets, software and the plethora of consumer electronic devices.

Just like real vitamins, proactive usability needs to be taken in daily doses and takes commitment.  But that doesn’t make it hard.  Besides, consider the benefits.  In the end, the products that standout all share common design traits, including good usability that has been planned for.  Google, iPod, Nokia mobiles, Tivo, Amazon, Flickr – all products that are easy to use and enjoyable.

What about what you’re working on now?  How can you start taking usability vitamin supplements?

August 8, 2005. Posted by in user experience, user testing.

Sign up to our email newsletter

Sign up to receive regular updates on our latest projects, research, and other news in the world of usability.

Email addresses are not sold or given to anyone.

Twitter updates